Intellectuals and the state: the resilience and decline of Neo-Confucianism as state ideology in Joseon Korea
Sun Kwan Song
SOAS Research Online (SOAS University of London) · 2014 · 인용 1
Intellectuals and the State: The Resilience and Decline of Neo-Confucianism as State Ideology in Joseon Korea This dissertation attempts to revaluate the role of Neo-Confucianism in the historical development of the Joseon dynasty, in particular in relation to the eighteenth and the early nineteenth century.Japanese imperialist historians wanted to justify their colonization by emphasizing the backwardness of Joseon Neo-Confucianism, and Korean nationalist historians wanted to refute Japanese imperialist historiography by finding the seed of modernity in the late Joseon intellectual trends they labelled as Silhak, 'Practical Learning', a school of thought they argued developed in opposition to stagnant and conservative Neo-Confucianism.Despite their different agendas both groups based their research on the assumption that what Korea needed at the time was to "modernize."Recent research on Joseon intellectual history has attempted to move beyond the teleological question of Korean modernization, but it has largely been limited to late eighteenth century trends and certain schools of thought.This study, however, situates these intellectual developments in the longer term historical development of the dynasty, and by focusing on how Neo-Confucian intellectuals reacted to a series of dynastic challenges and formulated further Neo-Confucian ideology to overcome them.This provides a more comprehensive understanding of both the role played by Neo-Confucianism as state ideology throughout the dynasty and the reasons for why this intellectual discourse lost much of its momentum in the early nineteenth century. Stylistic ConventionsFor Korean names and terms, I follow the Korean Romanization Rule (Korean Ministry of Culture and Tourism 2000-8) rather than McCune-Reischauer system.Some English users have become used to the McCune-Reischauer, but it is rare to use this in contemporary Korea.However, in some cases, in particular in relation to popular family names such as Gim, Pak and Go, appear as Kim, Park and Ko, according to the McCune-Reischauer system.Kim, Park and Ko were already permanent.However, in the case of Lee and Choi these are transcribed as Yi and Choe since these usages have become popular.The cases of Silla, Goryeo and Joseon are also followed according to the Korean Romaniztion Rule.The only exceptions to this are books published in English by Korean authors who use variant forms of Romanization.All Chinese personal and place names are rendered using the pinyin system of Romanization without tone marks.Japanese names and terms are rendered in the standard Hepburn system.With respect to citing specific original sources, I use modern page numbers or internet citations where possible.For the translation of some original sources into English, I follow James Legge, The Chinese Classics and Lee Baker et al., The Sourcebook of Korean Civilization.In the case of Joseon Wanjo Sillok (The Annals of the Joseon Dynasty) I use http://sillok.history.go.kr/main/main.jsp."Taejo Sillok 1392.8. 2.
4" means the year 1392, August, 2 nd , and 4 th episode, which refers to the lunar calendar.Confucian values such as Neo-Confucian morality or legitimacy.This discrimination against the meritorious group was their weapon to take political power from the meritorious group (chapter 1).The second mission was to survive the Imjin war and govern postbellum Joseon.They used Jaejojieun as a propaganda tool to turn people's concern away from domestic issues (including the Joseon court's maladministration) to international issues (Ming's relief force) (chapter 2).The third mission was to explain the peculiar international situation and resolve the resentment felt on being defeated by a barbarian, Qing.Sinocentrism was their answer (chapter 3).Ritual Learning was studied and utilised to rebuild Joseon according to a more concrete standard, Li (禮).Joseon Neo-Confucianism enjoyed its heyday during this period.However, their attentions began to wander off the expected paths (chapter 4).They failed to find an answer in the real world and began to change their focus toward more theoretical fields.Yet this also failed (chapter 5).Silhak would become the struggle of stray intellectuals (chapter 6). 6.This dissertation also avoids a recent scholarly tendency in that some historians have applauded the Joseon Neo-Confucianism of the eighteenth century, evaluating it as the pinnacle of Joseon civilization.6 However, this research underlines the sudden ending of Joseon Neo-Confucianism by examining the Horak Controversy.This research calls this phase the "intellectual wandering period."In fact, more research on eighteenth-century Joseon intellectual trends outside of Neo-Confucianism is needed.This included 6 Choe, Wansu, "Joseon Wangjoeui Munhwajeoljeonggi, Jingyeongsidae," 13-44.1.The Birth of Joseon Neo-Confucianism: Discourse of the Legitimate Heirs and Enshrinement There is no universally accepted date for the birth of Joseon Neo-Confucianism (朝鮮 性理學), therefore this needs analysis.I look at the discourse of the legitimate heirs and enshrinement (文廟從祀論議) which, I argue, is the true birth of Joseon Neo-Confucianism.I do this by analyzing the final five Joseon Neo-Confucian literati chosen to be enshrined (五賢), Kim Geongpil (金宏弼, 1454-1504), Jeong Yeochang (鄭汝昌, 1450-1504), Jo Gwangjo (趙光祖, 1482-1519), Yi Eonjeok (李彦迪, 1491-1553) and Yi Hwang (李滉, 1501-1570), to verify when Joseon Neo-Confucianism was ready to become a dominant ideology in the Joseon dynasty.The reason why I chose these five enshrined figures is because the first three literati demonstrated the power shift from the previous political power group, the meritorious courtiers, to the Neo-Confucian literati, and the other two figures produced extremely influential, original, and mature examples of independent Joseon Neo-Confucianism.I investigate the merit awarding system (功臣冊封) in order to compare the older standards of the non Neo-Confucian power group with the new standards of the Neo-Confucian literati to account for the change.In this chapter I also deal with the Four Literati Purge, which shows how the discourse of the heirs of legitimacy and enshrinement assumed a primary status in Joseon academic circles as well as its political field.It is during these days that Joseon Neo-Confucianism finally began. of Joseon's Neo-Confucian founders.He executed an elaborate and comprehensive theoretical criticism on Buddhism through his two main works: On the Mind, Material Force and Principle (心氣理篇, 1394) and Arguments against Buddha (佛氏雜辯, 1398).On the Mind, Material Force and Principle is a comparative study of Buddhism, Taoism and Confucianism from the point of view of Neo-Confucianism.Jeong argued in this book that Buddhists, Taoists and Confucians emphasize mind (心), material force (氣) and principle (理) respectively.He stressed that mind and material force cannot exist without principle.13 He argued that the most important values of Buddhism (mind), and Taoism (material force), and made them imperfect values.At the same time, he reinforced the status of Neo-Confucianism, which was needed for the new era, the Joseon dynasty.He also singled out the doctrines of Buddhism for more detailed criticism in his last work, Arguments against Buddha.In particular he vehemently criticized Buddhist knowledge theory that regarded the phenomenal world as an illusion (Sambongjip: 258-268).Jeong Dojeon also had a significant influence on the discourse of principle and material force (理氣論).His understanding of principle was not different from that of succeeding generations of Neo-Confucian literati.In other words, Jeong was an orthodox Neo-Confucian.Jeong stated in On the Mind, Material Force and Principle that material force is derived from principle, and principle is the origin of one's mind as well.He finally asserted that principle is a pure virtue and an immutable law and pre-existing on heaven and earth.14 Joseon Neo-Confucians' understanding of principle and material force was based on Jeong Dojeon's works.Yu Choha argues that Joseon Neo-13 Jeong, Dojeon, Sambongjip, 280-288.14 Jeong, Dojeon, Sambongjip, 276-280.with the rank of prime minister posthumously.24 Jeong's ascension seemed as if it would not to be stopped easily.During the reign of King Sejong, Jeong Mongju was exemplified as an example of loyalty (忠臣圖, chungsindo) in the book, Samganghaengsildo (三綱行實圖, Exemplars of the Three Moral Relationship). 25 Jeong Mongju was also discussed as a sage to be enshrined several times.26 Ironically, Jeong Mongju, who opposed the Joseon dynasty and was purged for it, was the first sage to be enshrined in the Joseon dynasty, while Jeong Dojeon and Gwon Geun were not.27 In intellectual terms it is hard to say that Jeong Dojeon was superior to Jeong Mongju, "the ancestor of the Eastern school of principle" (東方理學之宗).28 His theoretical criticism of Buddhism was not original and was in fact similar to that of Song dynasty scholarship.In addition, Deuchler argues that Jeong Dojeon was not a very deep thinker, 29 and de Bary also agrees that Jeong Dojeon does not rank among the great philosophers of Korea.30 On Kim Jajeom's (金自點, 1367-1433) memorial, however, Jeong Dojeon was estimated to be "as the only one true Neo-Confucian scholar." 31 Jeong Dojeon's contemporaries, like Pak Cho (朴礎, 1367-1454) and Gwon Junghwa (權仲和, 1322-1408) also praised Jeong Dojeon's faithful attitude to Neo-Confucianism.Pak Honggyu argues that Jeong Dojeon was intentionally neglected and excluded from the Neo-Confucian legitimate heir line by King Taejong, although Jeong 24