Dark Chamber and Light-Filled Room: Vermeer and the Camera Obscura
Seymour Charles
The Art Bulletin · 1964 · 인용 21
For over thirty years the literature on Vermeer of Delft has included first hints, then suggestions and, finally, all but direct statements that Vermeer used the forerunner of the modern photographic camera, the camera obscura, as an aid in making his paintings. Although Wilenski in the late 1920's put much more emphasis on the use of mirrors than on the camera obscura, he pointed to certain effects (distorted enlargement in foreground objects, for example) which can be observed in photographs and noted as “perhaps one of the ironies of art history that with a Kodak any child might now produce by accident a composition that a great artist like Vermeer had to use all his ingenuity … to achieve.”1 More penetrating was Hyatt Mayor's discussion in 1946 of the evidence favoring Vermeer's use of a mechanical aid; here he spoke not only of distortion in size of near objects, but of the tonality of Vermeer's color which he “blended as perfectly as the ground glass of a camera” and of the highlights on foreground objects which “break up into dots like globules of halation swimming on a ground glass.”2 To the objection that the camera's image is inverted, Mayor opposed the historically valid possibility of using either a second lens or else a mirror within the camera at a 45 degree angle to right the image. And he cited one record at least in the form of a tradition known to s'Gravesande in the eighteenth century that several earlier Dutch painters had studied and imitated, in their paintings, the effect of the camera obscura and its manner of showing nature.3 About ten years ago Lawrence Gowing set the artist quite apart from his contemporaries both on the count of his poetic richness of content and indifference to convention in drawing and modeling.
The summary of several pages of close analysis is brief but quite definite: “The technical part of it is plain. It is likely Vermeer made use of the camera obscura.”4 How did Vermeer acquire the necessary technical knowledge in optics? Gowing suggested the help of Vermeer's fellow citizen in Delft, Anthony van Leeuwenhoek, who in addition to his fame as designer, grinder and user of lenses, is also recorded as the executor of Vermeer's estate.