Fallingwater: Repairs to an Icon
Robert Silman
2000
Fallingwater is indeed a building that might be called an icon. That is, it is clearly an exceptional structure, one worth saving. In fact the American Institute of Architects recently voted it the most outstanding work of American architecture in the last 125 years.
The house is located in Pennsylvania some 72 miles southeast of Pittsburgh and is presently owned by the Western Pennsylvania Land Conservancy. This paper will describe how we went about analyzing the existing historic structure and what the proposed design for the repairs consists of. The major repair campaign is schedule to take place in the winter of 2001–2002.
Fallingwater is on the National Register of Historic Places and is one of the most famous houses in America, indeed in all of the world. It must be noted, and without apology, that in addressing serious structural problems such as this one, we have a great deal of difficulty following the strict letter of the Secretary of Interior's Standards for Historic Preservation — we cannot avoid serious interventions and cannot avoid irreversible actions. Our office began working on repairs to Frank Lloyd Wright houses some eight years ago, first with the Darwin D.
Martin House in Buffalo, New York and later at Wingspread in Racine, Wisconsin. As a result of a lecture presenting our solution to the difficult problems at Wingspread, the Executive Director of Fallingwater retained our firm to investigate structural problems at the house. We started in 1995 and issued the report of our initial findings to the Board in May 1996.
Subsequent evaluation resulted in a full four volume report on the structural conditions of the house. This paper will summarize the results of those findings and the proposed solution to the inherent problems.