Circumscription by Anthropogenic Environmental Destruction: An Expansion of Carneiro's (1970) Theory of the Origin of the State

D. Bruce Dickson

American Antiquity · 1987 · 인용 7

Carneiro (1970) asserts that social and environmental "circumscription" were primary stimuli for the emergence of the archaic state. He presents the environment as an essentially fixed set of natural conditions which impose constraints upon society. However, paleoenvironmental research and contemporary experience indicate that desertification, deforestation, salinization, and other salient environmental conditions confronting early states were neither fixed nor natural, but apparently dynamic products of direct human ecological intervention.

This paper reviews evidence from southern Mesopotamia and suggests that Carneiro's thesis be amended to include changing patterns of "artificial" circumscription brought about by anthropogenic environmental destruction.

🏛️ 거인의 어깨이 분야를 만든 논문들

국가의 기원을 자발적 합의가 아니라 제약된 환경에서의 경쟁으로 설명한 고전 이론입니다.

↳ 1987년 재해석본으로 연결

원저에는 초록이 없습니다 — 여기 쓰인 초록·이야기는 1987년 해설 논문에 기댑니다.

이야기를 쓰는 중…