Trypillia and Uruk

Johannes Müller, Susan Pollock

2016 · 인용 3

Dealing with the largest settlements of European prehistory, Trypillia mega-sites and the Late Trypillia development should be compared with population agglomerations that took place contemporarily in Southern Mesopotamia: the development of ‘agricultural towns’ and first cities during the Uruk-period. The only two phenomena of such huge population agglomerations worldwide at that time, within the Southern Buh and Dnipro interfluve and Southern Mesopotamia, display quite marked differences in historical outcome and consequences. While Trypillian mega-sites remained a chronologically short phenomenon of individual site durations no longer than 150 years, with the whole mega-site phenomenon restricted to about four centuries (c.

4000-3600 BCE), the Uruk development created ‘urban landscapes’ not only for a few centuries, but as a constant achievement for hundreds of years (starting around the beginning of the 4th millennium BCE). In Uruk, the ‘urban revolution’ began, while in Late Trypillia prehistoric small stratified societies continued (e.g. Kolesnikov, 1993; Kośko, 1995).

Thus, a structural comparison between both regionsand developments might help to answer different questions: Where are similarities and differences in the development of population agglomerations? Which role did the development of public buildings and the development of political institutions play? Which kinds of dependencies are visible between different settlements or subgroups within the population?

In both areas, we might also discuss the aspect of ruralization and urbanization, of management patterns within the mega-sites and cities, and of non-tributary and tributary systems. In a holistic approach, we observe that one society continues an egalitarian way of life without class differences, while the other develops a stratified society with a repressive state administration. A comparison of the settlement systems, demography, and the development of asymmetric relations may be starting points.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.