TAX TRANSFERS IN THE ROMAN EMPIRE
Luuk de Ligt
BRILL eBooks · 2002 · 인용 51
By LUUKDELIGTThe relationships between taxes, trade and the circulation of coin have been a fashionable topic .from the publication of Keith Hopkins' articles on the socalled taxes-and-trade model onwards.I Although the publications in question contained many methodological subtleties, their central thesis was relatively simple.The basic observation underlying Hopkins' analysis of the Roman imperial economy was that a large amount of tax money was taken from a limited number of tax-exporting provinces, such as Syria, Asia and Spain, in order to be spent in tax-consuming areas, such as Rome and the frontier provinces.Since there is no sign that the tax-exporting provinces were eventually drained of cash, it follows that they must have earned their tax money back by exporting goods either to Rome or to the peripheral parts of the empire.In short, taxation stimulated trade.According to Hopkins, taxation had the same commercializing effect within the tax-exporting provinces, as peasants had to earn the tax money they owed to the local tax collector.Finally, the need to pay taxes not only stimulated local and interregional trade but also pushed up the level of agricultural production, since the imposition of Roman taxation forced peasants to produce larger surpluses than before.During the past two decades this model of the Roman economy has been criticized and attacked on all kinds of grounds.To start with, some have argued that most taxes were paid in kind, not in cash?Others have pointed out that even if the Roman government did receive a large part of its tax income in cash it does not follow that money taxes were being paid at the ground level of peasant production.3 Challenging another aspect of the model, some scholars have also argued that Roman taxes bore heavily on the peasantry and caused many of them to abandon their farms.This would mean that taxation, instead of pushing up the level of agricultural production, might actually have depressed I K. Hopkins, 'Taxes and trade in the Roman empire', Journal 0/ Roman Studies 70 (1980), 101-125, restated with corrections in Id., 'Rome, taxes, rents and trade', Kodai 6/7 (1995/96), 41-75; Idem, 'Rents, taxes, trade and the city of Rome', in E. Lo Cascio, ed., Mercati permanenti e mercati periodici nel mondo romano (Bari 2000), 253-267.
2 R. Duncan Jones, Structure and scale in the Roman economy (Cambridge 1990), 189-194; P. Brunt, Roman imperial themes (Oxford 1990), 531.