Warta na obrzeżach Konstytucji: Dekonstrukcja mitu założycielskiego amerykańskiej sądowej kontroli konstytucyjności prawa

Sebastian Kubas

Ksiegarnia Akademicka Publishing eBooks · 2019 · 인용 13

A SENTRY ON THE FRINGES OF THE CONSTITUTION. DECONSTRUCTING THE FOUNDING MYTH OF AMERICAN JUDICIAL REVIEW This book is devoted to the myth of the Marbury v. Madison case and to the figure of Chief Justice John Marshall, whose traumas and talents set into motion the American judicial review.

According to the conventional narrative, in 1803 the Supreme Court established the principle of judicial review, allowing courts to rule on the constitutionality of federal laws. The Supreme Court under Chief Justice Marshall considered whether to compel President Thomas Jefferson’s Secretary of State, James Madison, to deliver the commission from the previous administration appointing William Marbury as a justice of the peace. In the process, the Supreme Court declared a provision of the Judiciary Act of 1789 unconstitutional.

I argue herein that in the cosmology of American judiciary, the Marbury case was the equivalent of the Big Bang, that is to say the originating single point, which included in a condensed form some features of the American judicial review that emerged slowly in the next two centuries. In this sense, the Marbury case - actually an incident unimportant in itself, unlike the Stuart v. Laird decision rendered six days later - on the one hand is the distorted and repressed past, but on the other hand, one can see in it the rudiment of the present.

I present here a historical inquiry into the origin of American judicial review, in which case, as I follow this detective association, the first part of the book, called “The Law and the Politics” may be treated as an investigation of the scene where the deed was not perpetrated, while the second part, called “The Politics and the Law”, may be seen as a search for motive of those to whom perpetration is commonly attributed.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.