Visual Support of the Neo-Gothic Project: “Contrasts” by A. W. N. Pugin

Vladislav V. Degtyarev

Journal of Integrative Cultural Studies · 2022

W. N. Pugin (1812–1852), a representative of the Gothic revival, known primarily as the co-author of the Houses of Parliament in London, was also a prolific writer, expressing his original views on the role of architecture in the contemporary society.

This article analyses Pugin’s most famous text— his treatise “Contrasts” (1836, 1841). Pugin’s contemporaries stressed his revolutionary role in the history of the Gothic revival. Architecture historians of the 20th and 21st centuries, however, tend to highlight his influence on urban studies.

We aim to demonstrate that these interpretations are based on two constituent parts of Pugin’s treatise studied separately. The text of “Contrasts” deals not with architecture as it is, but with the criticism of English Reformation, which was (as Pugin thought) organised solely by Henry VIII, and which destroyed the harmonious medieval society. According to Pugin, monasteries were the highest manifestation of this society.

As a Catholic convert, he tended to idealize both Christian and organic features of the medieval society, though monastic life was for him a certain Gesamtkunstwerk organized on the basis of Christian (i. e. Gothic) art. On the contrary, the illustrations, which were a separate album inside the book, demonstrated a profound understanding of the value of urban environment, therefore they are still presented as an example of progressive urban thought.

Reasonable as it is, this appraisal is based only on the illustrations, which are a separate entity inside the book. We can assume that Pugin (due to certain lack of intellectual discipline) was unable to pronounce some ideas which seemed obvious to him and which are more valuable for us than all his laments about Protestant vandalism.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.