Polluted realism in the art of Turner and Monet
John Edward Thornes
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · 2023 · 인용 5
Thoreau, the famous American environmentalist and philosopher, wrote in 1854:It is something to be able to paint a particular picture, or to carve a statue and so to make a few objects beautiful; but it is far more glorious to carve and paint the very atmosphere and medium through which we look … to affect the quality of the day, that is the highest of arts (2).The Realist Manifesto in art as set out in 1861 by Gustave Courbet argued that the realists wanted to represent things as they are, almost as if the artist did not exist.This paved the way for the Impressionist movement by hastening the departure of the dominant "classical" school.Realists could therefore paint their own vision of nature, but the artists found it difficult to keep their own interpretations out of the images.This led to the rise of Naturalism in art in which artists depict the actual scene without exaggeration or imagination.With naturalism what you see is what you get.Where do Turner and Monet sit in this regard?Probably somewhere between realism and naturalism?In PNAS, Albright and Huybers (3) successfully explore the impact of trends in 19th century air pollution in London and Paris on selected landscape paintings of Turner (1789 to 1862) and Monet (1840 to 1926).The paper offers a more sophisticated quantitative "content analysis" of a selection of Turner and Monet paintings, than has been published before.Applying novel mathematical techniques, they convincingly show that both artists truly portrayed the impact of air pollution on the urban atmosphere, and like Thoreau suggests, they successfully painted "the very atmosphere and medium through which we look."In view of the fact that those images are usually completed back in the studio, some time later, rather than in front of the scene, the term polluted realism sums up their art very well.