Does the frame of an artwork matter? Cultural framing and aesthetic judgments for abstract and representational art.
Kohinoor Monish Darda, Alexander P. Christensen, Anjan Kumar Chatterjee
Psychology of Aesthetics Creativity and the Arts · 2023 · 인용 17
Art is often thought to reflect the culture from which it comes, and viewers’ aesthetic experiences are influenced by sociocultural content depicted in artworks. Previous research suggests that people prefer artworks from their own cultures compared to another. We tested the hypotheses that viewers’ aesthetic experiences of art are modulated by cultural labels as expressed by artist names, and by sociocultural content depicted in the artwork, and predicted an in-group bias in people’s preferences.
Across three pre-registered experiments, we explored Northern American and Indian participants’ aesthetic judgements and preferences to abstract and representational artworks. In Experiment 1, when American abstract artworks were assigned with fictional American, Indian, Chinese, or Turkish artist names, we did not find evidence for an in-group bias – aesthetic ratings for artworks were similar across Indian and American participants, irrespective of the artist names to which they were attributed. In Experiment 2 using a two-alternative forced choice paradigm in which participants chose between two artworks attributed to Indian and American artists, we found no differences in Indian and American participant preferences.
We found slightly higher shared preferences for Indian artworks among Indian participants compared to American artworks and participants. Our findings from Experiments 1 and 2 that the appreciation of abstract artworks was not affected by a cultural label counter our prediction, based on previous reports of in-group biases in aesthetic judgments. In Experiment 3, we found a small in-group preference for Indian and American/European representational artworks – participants preferred artworks that depicted content from their own culture compared to another.
Effects across all experiments persisted when controlling for participants’ age, education, art experience, and openness to experience. The modulation of art perception and appreciation by contextual information and knowledge systems may be flexible, and more influenced by cultural content depicted in artworks than simple cultural framing.