Lowest-low Fertility and Super-aged Society: Causes and Impacts of the Extreme Population Structure, and Policy Options

In Do Hwang, Yunmi Nam, Won Sung, Seri Shim, Jiin Yeom, Byongju Lee, Harim Lee, Jongwoo Chung, Tae Hyoung Cho, Young Jun Choi, Seolwoong Hwang, Minkyu Son

SSRN Electronic Journal · 2024 · 인용 4

English Abstract: South Korea is a “lowest-low fertility” country facing a demographic challenge that is unprecedented both in terms of severity (the lowest fertility rate in the OECD in 2021 as well as the lowest in the world if Hong Kong is excluded) and duration (below 1.3 per woman for 21 consecutive years since 2002). The declining marriage rate has been a key contributor to this abnormally low fertility. The speed of aging of the population structure in South Korea has also been amongst the fastest in the world.

The decomposition of a 50-year time series found that the contributions of low fertility and increased life expectancy were 70% and 30%, respectively. Unless South Korea takes necessary steps to combat the trend, continued low fertility and accelerated population aging will pose a serious risk to both “growth” and “distribution.” Our analysis found that without effective policy responses, the probability of the Korean economy shrinking–growing at a rate of 0% or less–during the 2050s was as high as 68%. In regards to distribution, the results of analysis suggested that the rising share of elderly population with high levels of inequality could exacerbate overall economic inequality. The causes of lowest-low fertility, the main driver (70% contribution) of demographic aging, were analyzed on multiple levels (individuals, cities and provinces, and countries), revealing that “competitive pressure” and “insecurity” related to employment, housing, and child-rearing were the most important factors. The desired numbers of children were significantly lower for young persons who were under severe competitive pressure.

The results of the cross-region and cross-country panel analysis showed that population density, which is closely correlated with competitive pressure, had a negative (-) effect on the fertility rate. These findings suggest the importance of competitive pressure as a determinant of fertility. Employment and housing security were also found to influence fertility intentions significantly.

Marriage intentions varied widely depending on the employment status (whether or not employed, whether or not a regular employee). Meanwhile, in a survey experiment, the desired numbers of children were lower among respondents in the treatment group who were provided with information about housing costs than those in the control group. As a matter of fact, both employment and housing conditions have changed for the worse in recent decades.

The increase in non-regular employment has intensified competition for high-quality jobs and surging home prices have added to the competitive pressure felt by young Koreans. Support is therefore needed to reduce “insecurity” related to employment, housing, and childcare, as well as measures to ease “competitive pressure.” This must be furthermore combined with “structural policies” to address structural issues in the Korean economy that are fundamental causes of insecurity and excessive competition (duality of the labor market, high housing costs, overconcentration in the capital area). The problem of senior poverty must be tackled using a targeted approach that considers heterogeneities in elderly population in terms of health (whether they are able to work) and assets, consisting of three prongs (boosting labor income, monetizing fixed assets, and strengthening basic pension benefits). A series of scenarios were analyzed using the panel data of 35 OECD countries. The results suggested that effective policies resulting in improvements in employment, housing, and child-rearing conditions could lead to an increase in fertility rate.

Meanwhile, the results of a growth accounting analysis indicated that this could also boost the potential growth rate of the economy (a 0.2 increase in fertility rate leading to an increase of 0.1%p in potential growth rate during the 2040s).

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.