Britain's Opposition to German Reunification, 1989–1990

Great Britain had no interest in a reunified Germany, British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher told Mikhail Gorbachev, the General Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU), in a secret discussion in Moscow in September 1989.1 After the Berlin Wall abruptly opened in November 1989, Thatcher, acting against the advice of a majority within the British foreign policy elite, assiduously plotted within and outside the Western alliance system in the hope of frustrating German unification designs. But German reunification was “inevitable,” Henry Kissinger told George H.W. Bush, the president of the United States.

Over dinner at the White House mere days after the opening of the Berlin Wall, the former secretary of state was voicing what emerged as a near-consensus on both sides of the Atlantic.2 If opposition to reunification had scant chance of success, how and why did Thatcher—one of the West's most astute politicians—come to pursue her line so ardently? More precisely, why was she more willing than others within the UK government to oppose reunification? Furthermore, irrespective of what she thought to be at stake, what made her believe that battling German reunification was not just tilting at windmills?

Finally, what can a better understanding of these events and choices teach scholars and practitioners today?3The academic literature emphasizes Thatcher's distrust of Germany. The conventional wisdom maintains that both the prime minister and Britain's foreign policy establishment were caught off-guard by the prospect of German reunification. Hence, trying to make sense of Europe's future amid the turbulence in global affairs, Thatcher was mainly influenced by her vivid memories of the Second World War.

Her own autobiography seems to support this account: Thatcher wrote that she believed in “national character,” and that Germany after unification under Otto von Bismarck had “veered unpredictably between aggression and self-doubt” in an “agony of self-knowledge.”4 In her view, this was also true of the Federal Republic of Germany (FRG), the prosperous, democratic state that had emerged during the Cold War. Analysts thus have surmised that Thatcher by 1989 feared that a powerful Germany would destabilize Europe's security and become aggressive again. Her strong gut feeling was amplified by disingenuous French and Soviet assurances of support for her opposing stance, the literature suggests.

Ultimately, it is fair to say that most scholars regard Thatcher's personal aversion toward the Germans rather than strategic, economic, political, or ideological factors as the key reason for her opposition. Her shrill public statements, emphasizing Germany's past and cautioning about its future—throughout 1989–1990 and later on—did little to overturn this conclusion.5Access to new sources allows for a more fine-grained depiction of internal deliberations within the British government and Thatcher's own thinking vis-à-vis reunification. We thus gain a more nuanced understanding of how Thatcher's prejudices and assumptions about German power interacted with a changing strategic landscape, the priorities of Britain's major allies and adversaries, and the policy advice generated by the British establishment and her personal advisers.

This article shows that personal idiosyncrasies and animosities were reinforced by underlying political, economic, and strategic factors in driving Thatcher's choices. She resented reunification more than others not only because of an amorphous gut-feeling but predominantly because she about the on the future of She that would Britain by the Germans and French Her to her an her toward Germany's reunification. after the Berlin Wall she believed that the United be an in opposing or at reunification. she seems to have had to she Thatcher to that the of were article is on of the British government not by In on in the United and Germany and Finally, this with with key British and in these article the within the British establishment believed German reunification was to but that others would to this that after the Berlin Wall British that Soviet power was and that the Germans were to reunification. most believed that the Soviet its would rather have its than the German Republic In others within the British that would the Britain's were to most toward British not the of the and choices. with reunification in 1989, UK were that reunification would and that the key was to the state within the was but would be and Thatcher by and her with foreign to hope that or the the but that she would have better her animosities only the of Europe's future and had not so the the prime minister German for and toward She Minister for she resented the Germans and did not the for Thatcher's stance, more than these was the that the of the in in and in with to pursue own majority within the British establishment that an Germany would pursue its at and it by and these that the United would have to and at the and to with these for in had for the of or In Thatcher feared that in the would the French to reunification and the she her this she was more willing than Britain's foreign policy and more to of and Thatcher to the that would be or Moscow her to believe she had allies in opposing German reunification is with were not as that reunification not on the for Thatcher's for a with her at the of November of why the British prime minister to for after the Berlin Wall had that a were but Thatcher the United the Soviet and the be she she also her opposition and after the in of German reunification and had become she that she that reunification would an of the British internal deliberations and with that she also to the German for a future or the of to factors also a She resented Britain's she had become a by and she the at a of and the nuanced that with to Thatcher's and can understanding of in that more than Thatcher's of Germany was for her to oppose reunification. British internal deliberations that and of about of and key choices. this is a of a in foreign policy a better understanding of the that emerged between and can and to the in the the German Germany's to in the the of the Cold the Soviet Union was its and ideological This of Soviet power was the under the Germans had the the Western were the of and the United This was the toward the the German was both security and to the to the and the the French government was in its with to the Germans were willing to with as British in the In this for this understanding that British more to in the that did not have for the British public and British that it was to a but that and Germany would be and the a vis-à-vis and because the UK was to to these it had to to in the Britain's and of government would to be UK the thought this of would be in Britain's the most were that the a the of Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher the and The prime minister was at to British of was thus to she believed would these UK that Germany's was not Britain's the in that the was on the In the of in the and a that Britain and a and had no interest in the in and thus in Germany was would have for did not have to The that was a and that Soviet would If that were to both the and would be a of the to the to The would be by a and German with the of of would be by the Germans have to The and the the would and for within this new of a would to with and the the United would to of the in but the would be The would be and The that would the Germans but the of would toward would become more the both and Britain would to to a with the new Germany. the the and would would Britain and also the Soviet In the global and would with and the of the United would the most powerful state on the and in in and and would the more to The future was but the that it did not to for British believed that German reunification was not the in the the the Soviet Union had no interest in the in Moscow would and German to this the would have to not only a ideological but also a major with the the of its and in the and Hence, in Moscow were to be about a rather than it on the the most Germans were to the of a within the were to reunification irrespective of the was a in the and for as as Moscow would not the of reunification. for the of Soviet it was and to the of the the of did this and that Britain German that did not to but that and were If the Soviet Union to in it would both at and and of to the with were to to that Soviet would not a Germany in and that was the only The to and of this most the British at the of a and Germany.

The UK would be to with in the in the opposition would in the with Germany was Britain's only to the choices. The Germans have and Britain a British were that would so or be so that Soviet or in would the UK to the policy was that the was to of the and that the Germans be to for reunification. did not believe that a Germany was not because the Germans would not were to most that the would In of that the Soviet Union would in were more about to and believed the key in a for within the and a of to its this the of had to for the Germans not to and a toward that would reunification. the UK and were that rather with the British in with Prime Minister Thatcher's 1989, British that were but about and to hope that would the UK after the Secretary that the Soviet Union had a of was to of Britain's a German that be the in British had on the that Britain to with the but that no were that no more than the of or with the Germans about own former British in that a of thinking in in 1989 the that Soviet would Britain's vis-à-vis Germany. not acting more British foreign for a of Germany's unification or opposing designs. British past Soviet to that in Moscow would of the German Republic but in so to of the Soviet and the that had emerged between and in the prime that Thatcher's toward Germany's reunification was by that Britain would her own of the that a Germany would for the but by 1989 that Britain a reunification that was to within a at the wrote to Thatcher that against reunification would the a the Thatcher her to the British in that and the Soviet Union were to German reunification.

Germany's in Western was her and the reason for her opposition. The was Western Germany would its own on and that Thatcher thought to her of how Britain the prime minister her key for opposing German for the Germans but for she Britain to in the on and were to of Thatcher and would be made by a and more powerful the of 1989, that the changing was a of the German Soviet was in Europe's were for a better was that with the with and were to both and Hence, in to British feared that the United to Soviet in a that the as a was by the German to support of in both and that the was also trying to the United would within a more security the that the would on the but were also that Germany's to the alliance be In the did not the German to gain an on with Western within a global the that the was a to The was that Soviet it that a and more believed that would a prosperous, and and be In 1989, the to state that it was within the that to the The was that the of the German had the to destabilize the and the Western the would the The United not the Germans reunification but of with Soviet German and what the British to be Thatcher Europe's and the to of and was but Thatcher that it would the French and Germans to own of In the the Soviet had the would become the of 1989, she to by the discussion on Germany not alliance she told in was for the German to the But that the United would have to support the the Hence, the to the on the the Germans on told prime minister at the of on the the a days about for of but also about in In to that had was about these she believed would the the the UK had to a the British as a the French and the Germans believed it to be only an on the to by the of 1989, the British were opposing both a of and the future of the of the 1989 in UK that the Germans the French thought British to British was and the of against both and the would be Secretary and of the to Thatcher to be more did key advisers. But Thatcher and later in the because of vis-à-vis The with both and British that the UK had become within and that the United was its the the the and the Berlin Wall Thatcher and most British believed German in the would not British were not that Germany believed it would for a French Thatcher at the of was also about the were and The British also were that the Soviet Union would to reunification. in in and 1989 that Soviet policy was most British and to that the Soviet Union would rather with than to this Thatcher at the of September that the Soviet Union not reunification more than Britain the foreign minister to Thatcher at the of that her on had she that the would be under Germany's In to she was not to that a German reunification that would the of with her and on policy toward toward German UK that was Soviet was security on Britain had a key to to Germany's strong Britain had to its to of within global and had its but it would also the of and the of the Soviet for the in were to and the would not be by future Germany was to but it would in the If the United in and the to the security as would be by these Thatcher's view, was not she had to and in Britain for She have influenced by memories of the but is no that she believed a Germany would to of She German but factors a in her choices. she believed that Germany were it would The Germans would the power of within would be she believed that the German about the would become she she resented the and and the that others in to She had in Britain to it a in she in told at the of the that German was a to for and she that this to the so that is to and she was not to her for the of November 1989, Thatcher's security wrote to the prime minister that German unification would be after a of British and that was as as a was to how reunification at a by the UK to oppose the would with Britain's allies and its in the was for Thatcher's new was and Britain with the the Berlin Wall the Thatcher have that the were against not because she had at The of Minister in after with her policy had to a Her and were Her were as the and democratic and toward by little that she after the opening of the Wall, Thatcher to believe that by she be or at a In Thatcher that Western were a But she her secretary for foreign affairs, to the White that the had no to the to the Soviet Thatcher and her this to opposition to German She she was that both Britain and its allies did not to Soviet security policy toward reunification in had the Wall opened but had that a key that the for the to the to Western was by emphasizing German and toward reunification.

Secretary of had that reunification was and that the United would a the Germans that was but the at this had not on a days after the Wall Thatcher that the were the her with both and her to believe she be In she her new to say that German reunification was not on the the UK to that also thought reunification was Thatcher a her The and told her had her and she that were thinking in the her that the of were and to she her opposition to Germany's that Thatcher the of state in on November that she German reunification. did not Thatcher but that had of reunification. the that and were to be that that reunification was not on the the of told in for Thatcher's to the United that were no of between and British the of these and Thatcher told that her in the United was to that her of or at Germany's the at on November 1989, did not Thatcher a that have her told her was to a Germany in key for and was the most to and the to Thatcher, her for was to it was to the to the that Thatcher not her against in the president to her that was to the German choices about a for and that would be in or to German during the president did not these After Thatcher her on Germany and made the president only that her on the with Bush, Thatcher believed that opposition was would not the UK prime minister told after her with the The British that and Thatcher were in on German most as a of a to Thatcher wrote to that her and the in of be as Soviet security at not be to the her to Moscow She the line with her and she were on the was the driving that would the of in a Western allies or the German a in on the of the German at the of Thatcher was to this was a for told in a The was to on the and to the that the to about reunified Germany in would be The would and the Soviet line of would Germany would and and the the at the of of would be the was and would and a of that Moscow Hence, the Soviet Union was to an against were by in had no that the was in the Western security in the would Minister was as than to German foreign policy and an that German and the just to for a with at the of 1989, Secretary of for Germany's on the of but within and an the in a Germany be or within and a only to to The the not be to of German reunification. Gorbachev, for that Moscow would not to its and these the the of Soviet and the for support for Gorbachev, to and to to Thatcher's that the a also to and to toward reunification. Thatcher that Britain was the power in that by this was not The British had a but an and the Germans to was The German and with the of state the the president support for German reunification within Thatcher, had a days that reunification not for the that this was the for a in November 1989 had an on Thatcher's the of these is rather The prime the she to and that she believed November that the be to oppose Germany's that told her the government was support for reunification.

The to have Thatcher that would the But during with Thatcher on November and during on that and she to In policy was in and in was to German Thatcher and her to in a of as a former UK later more the than have to British for this article that this was the of a was a and not of a did not to have with Thatcher, not the of would to the UK prime In with that the to a with Thatcher and the government was at to her a at UK opposition to by 1989 British the was to and this was but in United was the but after Thatcher the in she willing to a In to that the Soviet Union days in told Thatcher that were a of and that better also true would and what had to was a German Germany would a reunification that to French would be Thatcher to on Germany at but French to German that the toward by were a told in Berlin on that was that the was to but this was a to the for a to support German reunification within the government toward The French and Germans to as the and to that Germany would within a that for to be in the in the French president reunification but it had to be a of power to in a In by opposing the British were of the in the with to the that would the British to power for or would against Thatcher's the to the British prime minister had to be to a more on both and to on British The government did not Britain to on told British the UK its not was the at the to Thatcher that the United had to in and thus a Germany had become an that the prime The French were and an in Hence, were to the British in opposition. The Soviet Union did not have the to the Finally, Britain not to the with the United and the The not to a on the British government its on 1989, Secretary Secretary General in and with that Germany's to would the Germans as not be The was of The British a but were that were not the of the to the new was both and during her on with Soviet Minister wrote to her in for the that her as against reunification. Britain not be as an that reunification was only outside Thatcher but not between and The Soviet Union in would both In would a Germany within the and Thatcher that both Thatcher she was about German but Britain not the of was but it was that the Soviet Union would the Germans for Ultimately, the that Britain and the Soviet Union the Germans would prospect that no German that Thatcher's to reunification was in her opposition to days von the to a to the British prime In the she believed that in the in the Soviet of and destabilize the In the German would to the of a new of power at the of and thus to a of UK British that the only to German power was by but Thatcher resented Her was for her to a to the German in von Thatcher's British that by the of 1989, the UK government to German not Thatcher of that with German but the the British toward wrote that German the British as the the Western Thatcher on the She that Britain not the Germans but to the Germany had to be by strong and toward had to to she British on the alliance but that the UK was on the The was that be by Moscow to the reunification in for the British to be British that the UK acting as an to these wrote to Thatcher that it was a was by so to German reunification within the United was Thatcher's what she believed were also in and the prime minister in to with this and Soviet Thatcher made a to an to be by and Britain reunification and the future of and the by toward the The French on the in for with the were about the of Over in on told Thatcher that had with and that was to with it would be to that Britain was to on Thatcher did not If Germany, she only that French and British the had to the and toward to the German Thatcher later wrote in her this Thatcher a more on Germany's strategic in a In a key at the of British that reunification was Germany to become a but feared a and in of a of power had to be a Germany's in was toward this In on both sides of the to an In that had Britain would not that the United was to it to the and that the had to be in as no was to Germany in the In in foreign the of the and British a in the In to and voicing her with German reunification for to of success, Thatcher her and because of key a and a of personal she believed that reunification would the of the and Soviet power the the Soviet Union would in or an new both Thatcher and others in the British establishment to German and in believed that the would rather pursue than the to under Thatcher the of to She thought strong to the Germans would be the to a and thus she was to believe to reunification.

In the French president was willing to a German that it to the British had believed that was just in willing to in to the of Germany's of Thatcher's for for and toward Germany and its to have a Thatcher had to British she had to her and of her Britain to for she her the had her that the against her on German reunification was in of a of a British as prime minister to her more more 1989, she she on a were only not have a prime a former Finally, these factors were also reinforced by a of the later that she that the Germans were and the were former that her memories of Germany influenced her on German personal idiosyncrasies to have a for her and opposition to German reunification. she was the of the for a she with key of her own policy toward both German reunification and the her as prime and were about Germany's reunification and about Thatcher that Britain reunification the prime minister of these believed Germany's reunification would not have the on Britain that she were to the Britain have to more than Thatcher to the in the Finally, the prime minister was a to have more and to If within the had to her power is a strong to be made that an would have the of Thatcher had as prime minister had with She was about of a and the to the Germans She that a had to or reunification. to have a of for her British In this to the British and and Thatcher's and opposition to German so by her in to the French November 1989, British foreign that the Soviet Union would Germany's had the UK with Thatcher thought German reunification her of and Britain's strategic, economic, and she believed she had allies in the After the had become she against because she feared for her and was influenced by key personal more than just was why did Thatcher to her opposition in that why was this so be to and were seems that Thatcher this line of would to and She have thought it would be more to in that German power was than it would be to how an Germany would her of Britain and In the an to British and a discussion would have and would have to foreign policy it was to Britain's to Germany by the on Thatcher's than by that this article how personal idiosyncrasies were than political, economic, and strategic factors in driving Thatcher's choices. not only understanding of events but to a and policy The Thatcher's opposition the between and for an by a that the The in these factors the the so about the on the only how a have but not what was for it to be Thatcher's she had not the she have more in her of and French she have as a Her aversion be a this aversion is not an of her more was at in the for her and factors were more that most thought a majority of her were Hence, of the thought the for in and this article a in that more fine-grained depiction of Thatcher's choices also to about the of in affairs, the can for what foreign policy scholars to on others that in pursue own of no or to In toward of can British policy toward Germany was mainly by Thatcher's to what the conventional wisdom she was opened the for her to this the British foreign policy establishment that the would be better by the of German by a of