Painting from Actual Scenery and Painting from Memory: Viewpoint and Angle of View in Landscape Paintings of the Late Joseon Dynasty

Tae‐Ho Lee

Journal of Korean Art & Archaeology · 2009

When it comes to true-view landscape paintings of the late Joseon Dynasty, it is clear that two different types were made. One type closely resembles the actual scenery portrayed, while the other bears little similarity. In this article, the author evaluates the difference between these two types of paintings by addressing the viewpoint and the angle of view adopted by the artist.

As for viewpoint, three types exist, namely bird’s-eye view, multi-point view and a moving point of view. Through this analysis it is possible to suggest whether a sketch of the scenery was done at the particular site and why artists changed their portrayals of scenes over time. Paintings of the former type are those that closely resemble the actual scenery.

Paintings of the latter type bear little similarity. Paintings, which do not resemble the actual scenery, were painted from memory after visiting the site and therefore the scenes were significantly changed, also in the case of paintings with place names. These kinds of paintings were predominantly made by literati painters such as Jeong Seon and his followers as well as Yi Insang, Heo Pil, and Yun Jehong.

Such paintings predate those which bear similarity to the actual scenery on the basis of a sketch done at the site. Kim Hongdo and his followers, as well as literati painters such as Shim Sajeong and Kang Sehwang come under this category. Jeong Seon was a painter who painted in reliance of his memory after personally traveling to a place of scenic beauty.

For this reason the scenes depicted in his true-view landscape paintings cannot be captured with a 28-50mm lens of camera. Only a wide-angle lens of less than 28mm or a panoramic camera can absorb Jeong Seon's scenes. Jeong Seon's field of vision was generally a horizontal viewpoint of 90-150 degrees or 180 degrees and so was very wide.

This was because he drew the landscapes from memory and in doing so he depicted ideal landscapes as expressed in a local Korean setting. The basis behind this is found in Neo-Confucianism and is matched by records stating that Jeong Seon painted according to the principles of the Book of Changes. It also reflects Jeong Seon's close association with literati scholars of the Seoin-Noron who had strong political power at the time.

With Kim Hongdo, who was not a literati painter but belonged to the Dohwaseo (圖畵署, Court Academy of Painting), there was new change in true-view landscape painting. He applied a different viewpoint from that of Jeong Seon whose style had dominated until the mid-18th century. Sites, which are included in Kim Hongdo's paintings, can be captured with the viewfinder of a camera mounted with a 50mm standard lens or a 35mm wide-angle lens.

This means landscape scenes with a horizontal angle of 47-62 degrees, which is most close to human viewpoint, were painted on the canvas. Such paintings can be argued to depict realistic scenes. In capturing actual scenes, Kim adopted a viewpoint, which was similar to that of European landscape paintings and European photographs of landscapes, which developed after the 17th century.

For this reason, Kim represented scenes in a real and vivid manner. Furthermore, in contrast to Jeong Seon, Kim painted not only landscapes of great beauty but also everyday scenes. The foundations for this change can also be argued to lie in the different ideology of the time.

While Jeong Seon's style is deeply imbedded within Neo-Confucian ideals of his time, Kim Hongdo represents the Post-Confucian (後性理學 or 脫性理學) cultural milieu of the late 18th century. In contrast, in the 19th century true-view landscape paintings declined in popularity, partially due to the conservatism of the time as encouraged by the ruling house.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.