The Politics of Attribution
Gary Taylor
Oxford University Press eBooks · 2025
Abstract The methods that determine the canon of Shakespeare, the New Testament, or Frederick Douglass are entangled with definitions of the cultural canon that shapes an ‘imagined community’. The more important a text, the more politicized its attribution will be. Even scholars are susceptible to ‘confirmation bias’ or ‘my-side-bias’, which makes us more likely to accept claims confirming what we already believe.
The rise of humanist philology challenged the textual authority of the Roman Catholic Church; the resulting polemics are directly related to nineteenth-century Baconian claims that none of the works attributed to Shakespeare were written by him. That anti-Stratfordite conspiracy theory then provoked a new twentieth-century textual orthodoxy, claiming that all the First Folio plays were written by Shakespeare alone. That modernist absolutism was as logically flawed as the Baconian and Oxfordian absolutism it challenged.
But it still underlies disputes about new scholarship on Shakespeare’s collaborations and his ‘bad quartos’.