Sounding Numbers, Fickle Anagrams, Chameleonic Alphabets and Carved Vowels
R. Larry Todd, Katharina Uhde
Boydell and Brewer eBooks · 2025
‘ Cest ce que chascuns na mie / Scens de trouver tel muserie ’ ‘Not every man / has enough skill to solve such a puzzle.’ Machaut, La Prise d’Alexandre , 1391–2 O f the preeminent fourteenth-century French composers, Guillaume de Machaut ( ca. 1300–77) also enjoyed a singular distinction as a poet during the period known as the Ars nova ( New Art ), in contrast to the earlier Ars antiqua ( Ancient Art ). He played a significant role in our narrative of early musical cryptography for finding diverse ways to project multiple authorial voices, some well enough hidden from the reader/listener to pose vexing riddles, not all of which, it seems, we possess sufficient skill to solve.
E vidently the first to use the term Ars nova was Jacques de Liege ( ca. 1260– post 1330) in his Speculum musicae ( The Mirror of Music , ca . 1330), a ‘voluminous and spectacularly learned treatise’ of medieval music theory.
His purpose was to expose ‘errors of the composers of the Ars nova and to demonstrate the validity of the teachings of the Ars antiqua ’. As a result, Jacques inveighed against the innovations of the new century that Machaut embraced while acknowledging in his music the lingering influence of the Ars antiqua . Among them was a relaxed – for Jacques – unprincipled treatment of dissonances he likened to a ‘great bestiality’: ‘It seemed as if an ass was dressed as a man, a nanny goat as a lion, a bird as a fish, a snake as a salmon’.
Above all, Jacques criticized the admission of ‘imperfect’ binary rhythmic values.