Jeong Do-jeon’s Neo-Confucian View of Monarchy and the Theory of the King’s Mind as the Arbiter of Success or Failure
Min-gyu Choi
The Society of History Education · 2026
This study examines the structure of the Neo-Confucian monarchical theory proposed by Jeong Do-jeon in response to the historical crisis of the decline of royal authority in the late Goryeo Dynasty, focusing on its core mechanism, the “Theory of the King’s Mind as the Arbiter of Success or Failure” (君主一心成敗論).Jeong Do-jeon identified the root causes of the neutralization of royal authority in private political operations and the moral defects of monarchs, subsequently establishing the logic for dynastic change. Drawing upon Song and Yuan Neo-Confucianism, he sought to assign a public role and status to the monarchy, envisioning the ruler as a legitimate arbiter of a public political system through the restoration of ethical morality. He emphasized a strict distinction of roles between the King and his ministers to rectify the discipline of the state, advocating for a governance system that provides practical benefits to the people through institutional frameworks.
Simultaneously, he designed a system of “Joint Governance between the King and Ministers” (君臣共治), wherein the monarch shares “Heavenly Duties” (Cheon-jik) with the literati bureaucracy rather than exercising arbitrary power. By implementing a system of ministerial responsibility and the oversight of the Censorate, he established an institutional foundation ensuring that politics for the people (民本) and for their welfare (爲民) functioned as a practical system.The core driving force for the stable operation of this public political order was the “Theory of the King’s Mind.” By subordinating the monarch’s mind to the Heavenly Principle (天理), Jeong attempted to overcome the innate temperamental limitations of hereditary kings and secure the centripetal force of a unified centralized system. His theory of crown prince education, which prioritized self-cultivation (涵養), functioned as a political-ideological mechanism through which the monarch’s voluntary pursuit of human ethics led to the stable management of public governing institutions.In conclusion, Jeong Do-jeon’s theory of monarchy logically integrated institutional reorganization with the ethical cultivation of the ruler within the unique context of the early Joseon Dynasty.
This serves as a significant scholarly indicator foreshadowing the “mind-centered academic trend” that became typical of monarchical theories throughout the Joseon era.