Lessons of Scale. Transformations of the Giant Order from Michelangelo to Piranesi, II, From Baroque Rome to Europe and Back Again
Daniel Sherer
Studi e ricerche di storia dell'architettura · 2026
The first part of this essay, which appeared in the previous issue of the present journal, traced the trajectories of the giant order from Michelangelo to Perrault. The second charts the divergent handling of the order in Bernini’s Sant’Andrea al Quirinale and Borromini’s San Carlo alle Quattro Fontane, examining how it shaped these projects and their subsequent impact. Offering disparate responses to Michelangelo, these churches provided antithetical models for a wide range of receptions of the order in Northern Italy (Guarini, Vittone, Juvarra), France (Perrault, Le Vau), England (Wren, Hawksmoor, Vanbrugh), the German-speaking lands (Neumann, Fischer von Erlach) and Bohemia (Santini-Aichel).
Central to this diffusion is the complex relationship between the order and period understandings of the sublime. The essay ends with a reading of the giant order in Piranesi’s prints. In them, the order’s monumentality is paradoxically augmented by the limited scale of the print medium.