Literary controversies regarding the Origins and Complexification of Jinhan and Byeonhan

Yeongnam Archaeological Review, 박대재

The Yeongnam Archaeological Society · 2026

Jinhan and Byeonhan, which constituted the Three Han, were the precursors and foundations of Silla and Gaya, respectively, and were complex societies each comprising 12 towns. In historical records, Byeonhan was more commonly referred to as “Byeonjin,” suggesting that its origins and identity were closely linked to those of Jinhan. The Records of the Three Kingdoms(Sanguozhi) states that Jinhan’s origins are linked to Chinese exiles who fled the Qin dynasty at the end of the 3rd century BCE, and that it was therefore also called “Qin-Han”; however, this is a misinterpretation stemming from a Sinocentric historical perspective and is difficult to accept at face value.

Jinhan was established following the fall of Wiman Joseon at the end of the 2nd century BCE, when refugees from Gojoseon migrated south; among these refugees were a large number of Chinese exiles from regions such as Yan and Qi. Jinhan was a society formed by the integration of Gojoseon refugees—including Chinese exiles—with indigenous groups, and Byeonhan appears to have been similar. Jinhan and Byeonhan were difficult to distinguish not only because of their overlapping populations but also because they were geographically intermingled and culturally similar.

The criteria used to distinguish the Three Han in sources such as Sanguozhi were based on their systems of foreign relations with China. Mahan and Jinhan conducted negotiations with China through their respective representatives, the “Mahanju” and the “Jinhanwang,” who served as the channels for foreign relations. In the early 3rd century, Byeonhan had a “King” who represented its twelve towns and maintained an independent maritime diplomatic system with the Daebang(Daifang) Commandery; however, in the late 3rd century, as a land-based diplomatic system connecting the Nangnang(Lelang) Commandery and Jinhan developed, Byeonhan shifted to conducting diplomacy with China through Jinhan.

Thus, the classification of the Three Han in works such as Sanguozhi was based on the existence of a “king” who served as an external sovereign (alliance leader) in the system of relations with China; this also illustrates the process by which the Three Han complexified into early states such as Baekje, Silla, and Gaya.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.