Registered Replication Report: Study 1 From Finkel, Rusbult, Kumashiro, & Hannon (2002).
Cheung Irene, Campbell Lorne, LeBel Etienne P, Ackerman Robert A, Aykutog˘lu Bülent, Bahník Šteˇpán, Bowen Jeffrey D, Bredow Carrie A, Bromberg Christopher, Caprariello Peter A, Carcedo Rodrigo J, Carson Kevin J, Cobb Rebecca J, Collins Nancy L, Corretti Conrad A, DiDonato Theresa E, Ellithorpe Chelsea, Fernández-Rouco Noelia, Fuglestad Paul T, Goldberg Rebecca M, Golom Frank D, Gündog˘du-Aktürk Elçin, Hoplock Lisa B, Houdek Petr, Kane Heidi S, Kim John S, Kraus Sue, Leone Christopher T, Li Norman P, Logan Jill M, Millman Roanne D, Morry Marian M, Pink Jennifer C, Ritchey Taylor, Root Luna Lindsey M, Sinclair H Colleen, Stinson Danu Anthony, Sucharyna Tamara A, Tidwell Natasha D, Uysal Ahmet, Vranka Marek, Winczewski Lauren A, Yong Jose C
Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science · 2016 · PMID 27694468 · 인용 87
Finkel, Rusbult, Kumashiro, and Hannon (2002, Study 1) demonstrated a causal link between subjective commitment to a relationship and how people responded to hypothetical betrayals of that relationship. Participants primed to think about their commitment to their partner (high commitment) reacted to the betrayals with reduced exit and neglect responses relative to those primed to think about their independence from their partner (low commitment). The priming manipulation did not affect constructive voice and loyalty responses.
Although other studies have demonstrated a correlation between subjective commitment and responses to betrayal, this study provides the only experimental evidence that inducing changes to subjective commitment can causally affect forgiveness responses. This Registered Replication Report (RRR) meta-analytically combines the results of 16 new direct replications of the original study, all of which followed a standardized, vetted, and preregistered protocol. The results showed little effect of the priming manipulation on the forgiveness outcome measures, but it also did not observe an effect of priming on subjective commitment, so the manipulation did not work as it had in the original study.
We discuss possible explanations for the discrepancy between the findings from this RRR and the original study.