Suggestive but not conclusive: An independent meta-analysis on the auditory benefits of learning to play a musical instrument. Commentary on.

Román-Caballero Rafael, Lupiáñez Juan

Neuroscience and biobehavioral reviews · 2022 · PMID 36252825 · 인용 13

PubMed ↗DOI ↗

The literature on musical training suggests benefits of this activity on auditory skills (i.e., near transfer) and general cognitive abilities (i.e., far transfer). However, other positions have taken those results more skeptically, rather arguing that studies with positive outcomes suffer from methodological issues that impede inferences of causality. In the context of this debate, we conducted an independent meta-analysis similar to one recently published by Neves et al.'s, also showing auditory benefits of musical training.

Our meta-analysis suggests that the available evidence is not sufficient to reach firm conclusions as interventions with design-quality features (randomization and active control) are still scarce. Moreover, the reviewed studies measured auditory skills with tests based on same/different judgments that rely on short-term memory, therefore being less sensitive to changes produced by musicmaking experiences. Although the evidence is not conclusive, the results are in line with those observed with other cognitively stimulating activities and suggest a positive impact of musical training on auditory skills.

Thus, the available evidence does not support extreme versions of skepticism.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.