For History's Sake: On Costa v. ENEL, André Donner and the Eternal Secret of the Court of Justice's Deliberations
JHR, MC
European Constitutional Law Review · 2014 · 인용 9
André Donner and the Eternal Secret of the Court of Justice's Deliberations Fifty years ago, on 15 July 1964, the Court of Justice of what is now the European Union decided Costa v. ENEL.The judgment is often mentioned in one breath with the no less famous judgment of 5 February 1963 in Van Gend & Loos v. Nederlandse Administratie der Belastingen.Rightly so: together the two judgments brought about the Big Bang of the EU legal universe, providing it at the same time with a matrix to expand into.Certainly, alternate histories generally are a form of fiction, but it is no fantasy to say that if the Court had not recognised the (possibility of ) direct effect of EU law in the national legal orders in Van Gend & Loos and of the (internal) primacy of EU law over national law in Costa, the EU legal order would not have developed as it has.
1 Roughly, two different narratives have been proposed to explain why the Court of Justice ruled as it did in the two judgments.2 In the international law version, Community law is a subsystem of international law.To put it much too briefly, the Court of Justice did what any international court would have done with a treaty giving national courts the right and sometimes even the duty to ask questions, the answers to which are meant to guide the national courts' subsequent judgments: 'le droit international n'impose pas la primauté interne en tant que règle abstraite, mais elle impose une primauté d'application au stade administratif ou judiciare'.3 In the competing constitutional narrative, the Community stands closer to national than to international law and constitutes a new, proto-federal 1 Robert Lecourt, 'Quel eut été le droit des communautés sans les arrêts de 1963 et 1964?',Mélanges en hommage à Jean BOULOUIS (Dalloz 1991) p. 349.2 In fact, there is a whole array of sometimes only slightly diverging qualifications of the Community legal order: for an early oversight, see J.L. Iglesias Buigues, 'La nature juridique du droit communautaire', Cahiers de droit européen (1967) p.
503.3 This is the thesis of Bruno de Witte in his seminal 'Retour à "Costa".La primauté du droit communautaire à la lumière du droit international',