Nelson Goodman’s Autographic-Allographic Distinction in Architecture: The Case of Mies van der Rohe’s Barcelona Pavilion
Remei Capdevila-Werning
De Gruyter eBooks · 2009 · 인용 11
In Languages of Art, Nelson Goodman proposes the categories of the autographic and the allographic to philosophically distinguish between an original work and its copy, reproduction, or forgery.However clear these distinctions might be in cases such as painting or music, difficulties arise when dealing with architecture, for our judgments regarding the identity of an architectural work cannot be indisputably classified according to Goodman's categories.Thus, first, I will discuss the scope of Goodman's autographic and allographic criteria to identify an architectural work.Second, I will examine the specific case of Mies van der Rohe's Barcelona Pavilion, first built in 1929 and reconstructed in 1986, to show how the allographic and the autographic are inextricably linked when establishing the identity of architectural works.Furthermore, I will argue that Goodman's statements on the identity status of architecture need to be reconsidered.