The 1816–17 Frankensteins: An Alternative Reconstruction of Their Composition
David Ketterer
English studies in Canada · 2001
Charles E. Robinson’s magisterial edition of The Frankenstein Notebooks may inaccurately present the composition history of Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley’s novel and thereby obscure its 27 October 1816 development from an alchemical, gothic ur-text, epitomized in the Notebook B “magical” creation of the monster’s mate, to a proto-science- fiction Last Draft/Revised Last Draft, epitomized in the Notebook A “scientific” creation of the monster. Was the approximate first half of Frankenstein in Notebook A written, as seems natural, before the remainder in Notebook B?
Or did — as significant evidence suggests — Notebook B largely precede Notebook A because Shelley circled back to rewrite that first half in Notebook A?