Adolf Loos and the Aphoristic Style: Rhetorical Practice in Early Twentieth-Century Design Criticism

John V. Maciuika

Bloomsbury Publishing Plc eBooks · 2010 · 인용 3

Adolf Loos has been described in annals of architectural and design history as individual most responsible for introducing principles of abstract, austere, orthogonal design into numerous pre-World War I Viennese buildings.' His early commissions-the Steiner House of 1908, Scheu House of 1910, and others-are generally interpreted as embodiments of maxims contained in his most famous 1908 essay, Ornament and Crime. As one of most radical polemics of design criticism of twentieth century, this essay gained Loos considerable notoriety in way in which it violently denounced, and then claimed to close door forever on, an arbitrary use of ornaments that had predominated in Viennese architecture and applied arts for decades. Employing a series of grand rhetorical gestures to denounce nineteenth-century historicism as well as newer styles being explored by Austrian Secession, Deutscher Werkbund, and Wiener Werkstatte, Loos's written and built works generally are credited with inventing forms that inspired countless modernist architects to embrace abstraction and International Style of 1920s.2 Succeeding generations of scholars and architects have treated Loos with varying degrees of sophistication, analyzing his buildings as expressions of his cultural polemics, connecting him loosely with other Viennese cultural innovators, or mining his writings for justifications of new directions in late-twentieth-century architecture.

Among most illuminating analyses of Loos's complex, anti-systematic philosophy are those of architectural historian Stanford Anderson. Anderson has argued that Loos's critical breakthrough consisted of developing an awareness of how competing conventions and practices-drawing, photography, master craftsmanship and building, and production of art-could constructively criticize one another from within respective, sovereign domains of praxis.3 Instructive for understanding Loos's approach to process of building and making, Anderson's work nevertheless leaves open question of how Loos used language in particular ways to advance his ground-breaking design philosophy. This article contrasts Loos's celebrated early design criticism with certain rhetorical practices in his writings, insofar as field of rhetoric traditionally has concerned itself with the way discourses are constructed in order to achieve certain effects.

This 1 This line of interpretation was inaugurated by Nicholas Pevsner in Pioneers of Modern Movement From William Morris to Walter Gropius (London: Faber & Faber, 1936), 188-92. 2 For example, Loos is said to prefigure International Style by at least eight years in Kenneth Frampton, Modem Architecture: A History(New York: Thames and Hudson, 1980), 90-95. 3 Stanford Anderson, Critical Conventionalism: Assemblage /(1986): 6-23, quoted in Stanford Anderson, Critical Conventionalism: The History of Midgard: Journal of Architectural Theory and Criticism, 1: 1 (1990): 47.

The architectural theorist Massimo Cacciari characterizes Loos's philosophy as negative thought that seeks to give an order to absence of synthesis. See Massimo Cacciari, Architecture and Nihilism: On Philosophy of Modem Architecture, trans. by Steven Sartarelli (New Haven: Yale, 1993), 37. ( Copyright 2000 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Design Issues: Volume 16, Number 2 Summer 2000 75

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.