Introduction

Sven Dupré

Techne. · 2019

This book is about the development of optics and perspective between the fifteenth and seventeenth centuries.It intervenes in two distinct historiographies: firstly, the history of perspective, an interdisciplinary field of study, to which primarily art historians and historians of science have contributed, and which developed in the wake of Erwin Panofsky's foundational study Perspective as Symbolic Form (1927); and secondly, the history of optics, a sub-field within the history of science, of which the contours have been outlined in David Lindberg's classic study of the history of optics Theories of Vision.From al-Kindi to Kepler (1976). 1 Both fields of study come with their defining experiments and canonical texts.For Panofsky, Filippo Brunelleschi's peephole and panel experiments in front of the Baptistery and the Palazzo Vecchio in early fifteenth-century Florence marked the invention of linear perspective.He cast Brunelleschi's invention as pointing forward to the first codification of perspectival procedures in Leon Battista Alberti's On Painting, a method of construction which, based on nineteenth-century German scholarship, Panofsky elevated to the status of 'costruzione legittima'.Lindberg, in his turn, considered the medieval texts of Roger Bacon, John Pecham, and Witelo as the canon of optics (or perspectiva, foremost to be defined as a theory of vision) connecting the reception of Ibn al-Haytham (known as Alhacen) with the work of Johannes Kepler at the beginning of the seventeenth century.Panofsky wrote Perspective as Symbolic Form at a time when scholarship on the history of optics, and medieval optics and the reception of Alhacen in particular, was still largely non-existent.However, more is at hand in the separation of the histories of optics and perspective than simply ignorance, which can be remedied by the progress of scholarship.Looked at from the other side of the divide, Lindberg discussed perspective as an impoverished application of optical theory with no development of its own and very little consequence for the route taken by the discipline of optics.More recent scholarship in the history of optics by Gérard Simon and A. Mark Smith is more attentive to perspective and art and disagrees with Lindberg's embracement of continuity of optics from Antiquity to Kepler, 1 Erwin Panofsky, Perspective as Symbolic Form, trans.by Christopher S.

Wood (New York: Zone Books, 1997); David C. Lindberg, Theories of Vision.From al-Kindi to Kepler (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976).I have discussed the historiography in Sven Dupré, 'The Historiography of Perspective and "Reflexy-Const" in Netherlandish Art', Nederlands Kunsthistorisch Jaarboek, 61 (2011), 35-60.while leaving Lindberg's basic assumption of a well-defined separation between optics and perspective intact. 2 Panofsky's own position in Perspective as Symbolic Form is rather ambivalent: while he recognizes the multiplicity of perspectives, especially ancient and modern ones, as well as different ways of constructing perspective, the one often more natural than the other, there are equally numerous passages in the book in which he privileges the costruzione legittima and a teleological view separating the histories of optics and perspective.Remarkably, despite his own ambivalence, Panofsky's most whiggish definition of perspective still haunts present-day scholarship on the history of perspective.Most recently, Hans Belting even revived Panofsky's notion of perspective as 'symbolic form', implying that it was 'expressive' of Renaissance culture.3 While Ibn al-Haytham plays a crucial role for Belting, the argument hinges on a problematically essentialist definition of two cultures, as well as an equally problematic separation of optics and perspective.Recent scholarship in the history of perspective has more strongly embedded the rise of perspective in the history of optics.In L'Hypothèse d'Oxford (1998) Dominique Raynaud attributed the highest importance to optics, a well-developed discipline in the Middle Ages in the hands of the Franciscans Robert Grosseteste, Roger Bacon and John Pecham, as a body of knowledge available to the artisans and craftsmen inventing linear perspective.And in a more recent book, Raynaud showed why, given the importance of the diffusion of Franciscan optics to the rise of perspective, it emerged in central Italy (rather than Oxford, the cradle of Franciscan optics, or the medieval Islamic world).4 Most recently, Pietro Roccasecca proposed a new reading of Alberti's On Painting, replacing Panofsky's interpretation of Alberti's perspective as costruzione legittima with an emphasis on the importance of Alhacen's optics to Alberti's perspective.5 Most importantly, these studies have downplayed the significance of the invention of perspective as a singular moment in the hands of one individual (Brunelleschi).Contrary to Panofsky's elevation of Alberti's perspective as the costruzione legittima, it has been shown, on the basis of the study of the material practices of painters in imitating and representing the 2 A.

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.