Literary Impressionism
Max Saunders
Blackwell Publishing Ltd eBooks · 2007 · 인용 60
The essay proceeds by a series of contrasts. It considers contrasting definitions of ‘impressionism’in painting : contributors to the group exhibitions from 1874-86 (which included some artists such as Cézanne and Gaugin, and Seurat, who went on to develop styles that would later be categorized as post-impressionist) ; or the broader aesthetic position. An emphasis on visuality realigns the function of light in art from a sign of spiritual significance to an analysis of perceptual experience and individual psychology.
Richard Brettell’s distinction is discussed, between ‘Transparent’impressionism (in which ‘the subject of the painting is the entire visual field in front of the painter’) and ‘Mediated’(in which the visual field is ‘as a social world in which the figure and its various « grounds » must be analysed to be understood’). There was two-way traffic between impressionism in painting and literature. While critics like the redoubtable Ferdinand Brunetière were soon discussing impressionism in fiction, Baudelaire’s essay, ‘The Painter of Modern Life’(1863) could be said to have written the manifesto for the painters ‘avant la tache’; as had Walter Pater in England.
The essay then contrasts two accounts of impressionism in literature : one which sees it as strictly coeval with its pictorial equivalent, and falling between realism and modernism ; another which sees it as originating in the realism and naturalism of Flaubert and Maupassant, and continuing into the modernism of the 1930s in writers like Virginia Woolf. The initial resistance to identifying as impressionist by James and Conrad is considered ; despite their increasing emphasis on the impression. By contrast, Ford Madox Ford consistently proclaimed himself impressionist, and prolifically advocated the more capacious version of the movement.
His own definitions and models of impressionism in literature themselves fall into two kinds of effect : one in which impressions are superimposed simultaneously ; and one in which contrasting views follow each other in sequence, producing an effect of instability and uncertainty. Literary impressionism is particularly drawn to moments of defamiliarisation, when a character’s identity is threatened, when their set ways of being and doing and perceiving are disrupted, and their experience acquires a rawness and directness that makes it more real for us. In this it approaches to the stream of consciousness, which modernism was to develop out of Impressionism.
It also makes us more aware of the medium, construction, composition, form, techniques, just as visual Impressionism intensifies awareness of the picture surface. Woolf is discussed as an exemplary figure in combining impressionism and modernism. Yet her rejection of plot stands as one reason why modernist and subsequent critics have found impressionism problematic in literature.
Other grounds are its privileging of the eye ; a concern that its attraction to the indistinct and ambiguous lends itself to wilful obfuscation ; and a related concern articulated by Marxist and postcolonial critics that what it obfuscates is social and political realities.