The Evolution of Constitutional Adjudication in Europe

Pedro Cruz Villalón

Oxford University Press eBooks · 2023 · 인용 5

Abstract The chapter outlines the evolution of constitutional adjudication in Europe over a period spawning from 1815 until 2009, considered from the perspective of the European legal space. It aims to present an overall concept of this evolution, in which developments described as purely national in earlier times can now be seen as European. The year 1918 marks the watershed in this long evolution.

The long nineteenth century shows a variety of scattered and largely insignificant institutions (judicial review of legislation, constitutional conflicts, individual complaints) related to the judicial guarantee of mostly monarchical and substantively poor constitutions. Reversely, the first afterwar period witnessed the emergence of a consistent notion of the normative—now republican—constitution in Europe that is consequently accompanied by the first examples (Austria, Czechoslovakia, Spain) of a characteristic system of judicial review, embodied in singular constitutional courts. Nevertheless, it is only in the time after 1945 when these first experiments take root.

The success of the German and Italian Courts leads to the gradual but unfailing spread of the model to the rest of Europe. Parallel to this, the notion of constitutional interpretation becomes the defining feature of constitutional adjudication. The end of this evolution is signalled by the emergence of a complex European judicial space, following the transfer of constitutional responsibilities to the EU Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights (judicial dialogue).

📄 이 논문을 인용한 Paperis 글

이 논문이 근거 목록에 올라 있는 Paperis 글입니다.