Thomas Frognall Dibdin as Ambrose Gunthio, Author of ‘A Running Commentary on the Hamlet of 1603’ (1825)
J. B. McGovern
Notes and Queries · 2025
In December 1825, the European Magazine ran a critically astute article titled ‘A Running Commentary on the Hamlet of 1603’, which appeared under the nom de plume ‘Ambrose Gunthio’. The pseudonymous surname was probably an allusion to a character called Gunthiof (Gunthionus) in the Gesta Danorum by Saxo Grammaticus, the original source of the Hamlet story.1 The same pseudonym was attached to a semi-plagiaristic ‘Dictionary of Love’ published in instalments in the Theatrical Inquisitor and The British Stage and Literary Cabinet between 1816 and 1819.2 The importance of the ‘Running Commentary’ is twofold. Firstly, its author was the earliest proponent of the theory that the First Quarto of Hamlet was a reported text.3 Secondly, he or she appended to the article some extracts from a now-lost ship’s journal that purported to record a performance of Hamlet off the west coast of Africa in 1607.4 Despite the significance of the ‘Running Commentary’ to later scholarship, its authorship has never been established.
In 1951, Sydney Race suggested John Payne Collier as the author for three reasons: he was an authority on Shakespeare, he wrote for the European Magazine, and the piece had an ‘impishly’ written postscript that sounded like Collier’s style.5 His view was convincingly falsified by G. Blakemore Evans in the following year, but it sometimes still resurfaces in the scholarship.6