The control of constitutionality in comparative perspective: models, scope and challenges in contemporary constitutionalism
Bouzid Mammeri
Tribunal de Justicia · 2024
Judicial review has been consolidated as an essential pillar of contemporary constitutionalism, ensuring the normative supremacy of the Constitution and the effective protection of fundamental rights. Within this framework, the present study aimed to analyze judicial review from a comparative perspective, identifying its main models, scope, and challenges in the context of the constitutional rule of law. Methodologically, the research was conducted under a qualitative legal approach, through a narrative review with systematic elements.
To this end, high-impact academic databases such as Scopus, Web of Science (WoS), and Scielo were consulted, along with relevant doctrinal and jurisprudential literature, prioritizing recent studies while not excluding essential classical contributions. The analysis focused on constitutional review systems in Europe and Latin America in order to establish meaningful comparisons. The results showed that classical models—diffuse and concentrated—present both strengths and limitations, which has led to the evolution toward hybrid systems that combine elements of both approaches.
Likewise, a trend toward convergence of models and an expansion of judicial review was identified, particularly in Latin America. However, significant challenges were also observed, such as interpretative fragmentation, the judicialization of politics, and difficulties in the effective enforcement of decisions. It was concluded that judicial review remains a fundamental mechanism for safeguarding the constitutional rule of law; however, its effectiveness depended on institutional, political, and cultural factors that shape its implementation and real scope